Here in the United States we are experiencing a remarkable effort to remove statues of heroes of the Confederacy from public areas. In Charlottesville an effort to protest the removal of one led to violence and the death of one person. I will not review the details of this, nor of the various demonstrations against hate-groups that occurred in many cities across the country following this. Nor will I detail a massive demonstration in Boston against a few people who wanted to assemble in support of “free speech”.
I wish to compare the present movement in America to remove or destroy statues and other memorials that refer to the leaders of the Confederacy to other movements that have occurred historically to cleanse a country of their past.
Way back in ancient Egypt Thomse III ordered the removal of all images and memorials of his stepmother Queen Hatshepsut. In modern times Egypt is working to remove all traces of Mubarak. In ancient Rome, “damnatio memoriae” was used to removed all memorials etc. of prior rulers when those following wished it. In China Mao Zedon had thousands of historical sites destroyed to rid his autocracy of capatalistic or traditional influence. Most recently the Talaban destroyed a couple Buddas and ISIS worked hard at blowing up many ancient treasures. And now the progressive liberal left in the United States is demanding that works of art reflecting the Confederacy be destroyed or hidden away somewhere.
A nation cannot erase its past by merely destroying works of art that refer back to it, nor should it. I have heard that it “all depends on the tone of the display”. In the U.S. one might imagine putting up a memorial to the internment of Japanese Americans during WWII. Presently any such memorial would not be looked at as a celebration of the governments imprisonment of these people but as an apology for what we did.
The problem seems to me to be that presently we cannot agree on what the “tone” of the statues of Confederate heroes in public places is. To most (according to a recent PBS poll) it still is one of historical importance to both whites and blacks. To some it is a celebration of slavery of blacks. We have no blacks enslaved in this country, although there might be some enslaved in the middle east yet today. Even those Americans who are descendants of slaves are generations from them and enjoy equality under the law. They, as well as other minorities, enjoy various affirmative perks not available to white Americans.
The present day cleansing of America of its past by destroying its statues and renaming streets, buildings and other means is merely the beginning of a total ethnic cleansing. A reasonable next step is to decide to redistribute from this group of white Americans any assets that they may seem to have because of their “white privilege”. This is what has occurred in South Africa and some other African nations. The nation should work toward removal of any white culture.
So, lets have America join Mao Zedon, the Taliban and ISIS and get to work cleansing the nation of all these relics of the past. Wait? Didn’t the majority of people think they should be kept? Oh well, the progressive liberal elites and the mainstream press must know best. Move on! Next is the Washington and Jefferson Memorials and Mount Rushmore.